80+ Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions for Family Fun & Laughter | Hilarious Game Ideas for Kids & Adults 2025
Thanksgiving is more than turkey and pie — it’s about connection, laughter, and cherished traditions. And what better way to make those moments memorable than with a round of Thanksgiving Would You Rather questions?
This simple game is perfect for every setting — from the classroom to the dinner table — sparking laughter, light-hearted debates, and sometimes surprisingly deep conversations. Whether you’re hosting a cozy family meal, a school event, or a Friendsgiving bash, these Thanksgiving Would You Rather game ideas will get everyone talking, smiling, and maybe even snorting with laughter.
🥧 What Is a Thanksgiving Would You Rather Game?
If you’ve ever played “Would You Rather?” you already know the basics. Players take turns asking questions that start with “Would you rather…” followed by two options — often equally silly, tricky, or hilarious.
For example:
“Would you rather eat only mashed potatoes for a week or give up dessert for a month?”
Everyone answers, explains their choice, and maybe tries to convince others to switch sides. The result? Endless laughs and a few friendly debates.
What makes the Thanksgiving version extra fun is the holiday twist — questions about food, family, gratitude, traditions, and of course, funny what-ifs involving turkeys and cranberry sauce.
🍁 How to Play the Thanksgiving Would You Rather Game
You don’t need fancy materials or complicated rules. Just gather your group and start asking!
Here are a few ways to set it up:
🎲 1. Around the Table
After dinner (or even before the meal begins), go around the table. Each person asks a Would You Rather Thanksgiving question from a list or from memory. Great icebreaker for mixed-age gatherings!
🖨️ 2. Printable Thanksgiving Would You Rather Cards
Make your own Thanksgiving Would You Rather cards or print some out. Cut them up, fold, and put them in a bowl. Let players draw one at a time.
🧩 3. Classroom or Office Version
Teachers and coworkers love this too! Use Thanksgiving Would You Rather for kids in classrooms or for adults at the office to lighten the mood before the long weekend.
🎉 4. Game Night Add-On
Mix it into your Thanksgiving trivia, bingo, or party games for variety. The key is to keep things lighthearted and inclusive.
🦃 Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions for Kids
Kids love the silliness of these questions! This set of Thanksgiving Would You Rather questions for kids is full of playful choices that are easy to understand and encourage imagination.
🍗 Funny & Easy for Younger Kids
- Would you rather eat only turkey or only pumpkin pie for a week?
- Would you rather be a turkey or a mashed potato?
- Would you rather wear a turkey hat or a pilgrim hat all day?
- Would you rather have gravy rain from the sky or mashed potato snow?
- Would you rather talk to animals or make your food talk back to you?
- Would you rather make a pie from candy or from vegetables?
- Would you rather smell like stuffing or cranberry sauce all day?
- Would you rather watch the Thanksgiving parade or a cartoon marathon?
- Would you rather eat dinner with a talking turkey or a polite pumpkin?
- Would you rather have feathers instead of hair or pumpkin pie instead of hands?
💡 Kid Tip: Encourage kids to explain why they picked their answer — it builds confidence and creativity.
🧡 Thanksgiving Would You Rather for Adults
Adults appreciate humor, nostalgia, and a touch of absurdity. These Thanksgiving Would You Rather for adults questions balance comedy and relatable scenarios — perfect over wine or dessert!
🥂 Funny & Thought-Provoking Choices
- Would you rather cook the entire Thanksgiving meal alone or do all the cleanup?
- Would you rather host your in-laws or your boss for Thanksgiving dinner?
- Would you rather eat undercooked turkey or overcooked stuffing?
- Would you rather run out of wine or run out of gravy mid-dinner?
- Would you rather spend Thanksgiving without Wi-Fi or without dessert?
- Would you rather give a heartfelt toast or perform a silly dance before dinner?
- Would you rather have your Thanksgiving meal televised or critiqued by Gordon Ramsay?
- Would you rather deal with a power outage during dinner or a last-minute guest list change?
- Would you rather deep-fry the turkey or try a vegan Thanksgiving?
- Would you rather have a Thanksgiving meal catered or homemade but burnt?
💬 Adult Tip: Mix these into cocktail hour or dessert time for casual fun.
Related Article: 100 Thanksgiving Trivia Questions to Ask: Fun, Food, and Festivities
🧑🤝🧑 Family-Friendly Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions
Families love games that bring everyone together. These questions work well for all ages — they’re funny, wholesome, and spark lively conversation.
🏠 Cozy & Heartwarming Scenarios
- Would you rather spend Thanksgiving at home or travel somewhere warm?
- Would you rather cook together or order takeout as a family?
- Would you rather eat dinner in your pajamas or dress up fancy?
- Would you rather have a pet turkey or a pet pumpkin?
- Would you rather watch football or play a board game after dinner?
- Would you rather say what you’re thankful for before or after dessert?
- Would you rather start dinner early or have a midnight Thanksgiving feast?
- Would you rather invite all your neighbors or keep it small and cozy?
- Would you rather decorate your home with pumpkins or fall leaves?
- Would you rather skip Thanksgiving or Christmas?
✨ Family Tip: Let kids read the questions aloud — they love being “game hosts.”
😂 Funny Would You Rather Thanksgiving Questions
Inject humor into your gathering with these hilarious and sometimes downright ridiculous prompts.
🦃 Just for Laughs
- Would you rather your turkey tell bad jokes or your pie sing love songs?
- Would you rather bathe in gravy or swim in mashed potatoes?
- Would you rather wear a turkey costume all day or gobble every time you speak?
- Would you rather accidentally drop the turkey or spill cranberry sauce on your guest?
- Would you rather have stuffing in your shoes or gravy in your hair?
- Would you rather eat dessert before dinner or dinner for breakfast?
- Would you rather live in a cornucopia or a pie crust house?
- Would you rather only talk in turkey gobbles for a day or sing everything you say?
- Would you rather get caught sneaking food early or forget to turn off the oven?
- Would you rather have to cook with chopsticks or eat with a ladle?
🤣 Pro Tip: Use these during awkward silences or after-dinner food comas to keep energy high.
📚 Thanksgiving Would You Rather for Classrooms
Teachers love this activity because it blends fun with social learning. Kids practice speaking, listening, and reasoning — all while giggling.
🍂 Classroom-Approved Questions
- Would you rather make a paper turkey or a paper pie?
- Would you rather draw what you’re thankful for or write about it?
- Would you rather sit next to a giant turkey or a giant pumpkin in class?
- Would you rather eat school lunch Thanksgiving or home-cooked leftovers?
- Would you rather read about pilgrims or turkeys?
- Would you rather be the parade float or the balloon handler?
- Would you rather decorate the classroom with leaves or acorns?
- Would you rather learn how to make cranberry sauce or pumpkin pie?
- Would you rather have a one-day Thanksgiving break or two half-days?
- Would you rather do math about pies or turkeys?
👩🏫 Teacher Tip: Turn it into a writing prompt — students can explain their choice in short paragraphs.
Related Article: Would You Rather Christmas Edition
🏈 Thanksgiving Would You Rather for Friendsgiving Parties
Friendsgiving is where the laughter never stops — and neither should the questions! Use these hilarious prompts to spark conversations between bites and cheers.
🍷 For Friends & Fun-Loving Adults
- Would you rather host Friendsgiving or just bring dessert?
- Would you rather forget to defrost the turkey or forget the dessert?
- Would you rather be responsible for the playlist or the pie?
- Would you rather spill gravy on your outfit or knock over the wine?
- Would you rather give a toast in front of everyone or lead a group game?
- Would you rather eat only sides or only dessert?
- Would you rather post every meal on Instagram or keep it private?
- Would you rather have your ex show up or your boss?
- Would you rather have to say “gobble gobble” before every sentence or dance before sitting down?
- Would you rather spend Friendsgiving indoors or around a bonfire?
🎉 Party Tip: Print your questions on decorative cards for a cute table game.
🍽️ Thanksgiving Food-Themed Would You Rather Questions
Food is the star of Thanksgiving, so naturally, we have a section just for the delicious part of the holiday!
🥧 Delicious Dilemmas
- Would you rather eat only pumpkin pie or only apple pie forever?
- Would you rather have unlimited gravy or unlimited stuffing?
- Would you rather eat cranberry sauce with every meal or never again?
- Would you rather skip turkey or skip dessert?
- Would you rather eat everything cold or everything burnt?
- Would you rather only eat leftovers for a week or fast for a day?
- Would you rather drink gravy like soup or eat pie with your hands?
- Would you rather cook the turkey or bake all the pies?
- Would you rather eat with no utensils or no napkins?
- Would you rather accidentally drop your pie or spill the gravy boat?
🍴 Foodie Tip: These are great conversation starters while everyone’s serving seconds!
💬 Gratitude & Heartwarming Would You Rather Questions
Add meaning to your holiday by mixing in gratitude-centered questions that inspire reflection and togetherness.
🌟 Thoughtful Choices
- Would you rather receive one big gift or give five small ones?
- Would you rather help cook or help clean up?
- Would you rather write thank-you notes or say them aloud?
- Would you rather spend Thanksgiving volunteering or relaxing at home?
- Would you rather have a long dinner or an extra-long nap?
- Would you rather make a new family tradition or relive an old one?
- Would you rather share your dessert or get an extra slice?
- Would you rather spend Thanksgiving with family or friends?
- Would you rather have a quiet dinner or a loud, laughter-filled one?
- Would you rather be remembered for your cooking or your kindness?
💖 Family Activity: After answering, go around and share one thing you’re thankful for.
📸 Creative Ways to Use These Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions
Beyond traditional play, here are fun ways to make these questions part of your celebration:
🎭 1. Photo Booth Prompts
Set up a Thanksgiving photo booth and let guests draw Would You Rather cards before posing — laughter guaranteed.
📱 2. Social Media Challenge
Post a daily “Would You Rather” on Instagram Stories or TikTok during Thanksgiving week. It’s fun, engaging, and great for families or brands.
🖋️ 3. Place Card Surprise
Print one question on each place card. Guests answer their question before eating.
📚 4. Classroom Morning Warm-Up
Teachers can use one question a day in November as a morning discussion starter.
🎮 5. Virtual Thanksgiving Game
If you’re celebrating remotely, play via Zoom or group chat — perfect icebreaker before dinner.
🍂 Why This Game Never Gets Old
The beauty of Thanksgiving Would You Rather lies in its simplicity — no setup, no cost, just creativity and laughter. It bridges generations, connects families, and turns ordinary dinners into lasting memories.
Each year, you can tweak the questions, add inside jokes, or even make your own custom Thanksgiving Would You Rather cards for a personalized touch.
Whether you’re planning a family night, school event, or festive party, these Would You Rather Thanksgiving questions (funny and thoughtful alike) are a timeless addition that’ll keep the laughter flowing long after the leftovers are gone.
Final Thoughts,
From silly choices to laugh-out-loud debates, these Thanksgiving Would You Rather questions bring everyone closer together — no screens, no stress, just good old-fashioned fun. Whether you print out our cards, jot them on napkins, or read them aloud between bites of pie, this game guarantees smiles across generations.
Remember, you don’t need fancy supplies or big budgets to make your holiday memorable — just creativity and a little laughter. So this year, keep the tradition alive with your own twist on Thanksgiving Would You Rather for kids and adults.
Now it’s your turn — gather your group, deal out the questions, and let the fun begin. 🦃✨
