Would You Rather Christmas Edition (2025): 75+ Hilarious, Thought-Provoking & Family-Friendly Holiday Questions
Snowflakes swirl outside, cocoa’s steaming in your favorite mug, and laughter fills the living room. What’s missing? A Would You Rather Christmas Edition game to keep the holiday cheer rolling!
Whether you’re looking for festive party entertainment, classroom icebreakers, or cozy family night fun, Would You Rather questions are a timeless and budget-friendly way to bond. They spark giggles, ignite imagination, and help everyone—from toddlers to grandparents—join the conversation.
In this post, you’ll find 75+ Christmas Would You Rather questions thoughtfully grouped by audience: toddlers, kids, teens, adults, friends, and even co-workers! We’ve mixed in everything from silly and sweet to deep and debate-worthy, plus printables and tips for turning it into a game night you’ll want to repeat every year.
Whether you’re planning a party, virtual gathering, or just adding fun to Christmas Eve, these Would You Rather Christmas questions are sure to become a favorite holiday tradition.
🎅 Would You Rather Questions for Kids
(Easy, funny, and full of Christmas magic — perfect for toddlers to grade schoolers!)
- Would you rather build a snowman or decorate a Christmas tree?
- Would you rather have elf ears or a glowing red nose?
- Would you rather eat only candy canes or only gingerbread men for a week?
- Would you rather ride in Santa’s sleigh or be one of his reindeer?
- Would you rather get 10 small gifts or one big gift?
- Would you rather open one present every day or all presents on Christmas Day?
- Would you rather wear jingle bells or Christmas lights as accessories?
- Would you rather have snow every day or no school for a month?
- Would you rather sing “Jingle Bells” every time you talk or walk like a reindeer?
- Would you rather meet Frosty the Snowman or Rudolph?
- Would you rather live in a gingerbread house or a toy workshop?
- Would you rather have hot cocoa or peppermint milkshakes forever?
- Would you rather wear a Santa suit or a Christmas tree costume to school?
- Would you rather hang ornaments or string popcorn garland?
- Would you rather have Christmas twice a year or your birthday twice a year?
Related Article: 80 Who’s Most Likely To Christmas Edition: Questions for Holiday Fun
🧑🎄 Christmas Would You Rather for Toddlers & Preschoolers
(Simple choices with visual imagination—great for little learners)
- Would you rather smell like cookies or pine trees?
- Would you rather color Christmas pictures or make crafts?
- Would you rather wear red or green pajamas?
- Would you rather pet a reindeer or ride a polar bear?
- Would you rather have marshmallows or whipped cream on your hot cocoa?
- Would you rather give hugs or high fives on Christmas?
- Would you rather put the star or the angel on the tree?
- Would you rather dance like a snowflake or hop like a reindeer?
- Would you rather unwrap gifts or hand them out?
- Would you rather have snowballs made of cotton or glitter?
Related Article: 200 Engaging Would You Rather Questions for Kids: Fun and Educational Ideas
🎁 Family-Friendly Christmas Would You Rather
(Perfect for game night or holiday dinner conversation starters)
- Would you rather open gifts on Christmas Eve or Christmas morning?
- Would you rather host Christmas dinner or attend it elsewhere?
- Would you rather watch “Home Alone” or “Elf” on repeat?
- Would you rather have a Christmas song stuck in your head for a week or wear an ugly sweater for a week?
- Would you rather bake cookies together or build gingerbread houses?
- Would you rather give gifts or receive gifts?
- Would you rather have matching pajamas or matching sweaters?
- Would you rather go sledding or ice skating?
- Would you rather eat only Christmas dinner leftovers or cookies for a week?
- Would you rather surprise someone with a big gift or be surprised?
Related Article: 50 Christmas Trivia Questions and Answers Everyone Should Try This Season!
📚 Would You Rather Christmas Questions for Classroom Use
(Icebreakers, quick prompts, or bell ringers for teachers and students)
- Would you rather have a snow day or a pajama day at school?
- Would you rather make Christmas cards or snowflake crafts?
- Would you rather be the elf who wraps presents or the one who delivers them?
- Would you rather sing Christmas carols in front of the class or do a silly dance?
- Would you rather write a letter to Santa or draw him a picture?
- Would you rather learn about reindeer or penguins?
- Would you rather hang paper snowflakes or color holiday posters?
- Would you rather have hot chocolate during recess or cookies after lunch?
- Would you rather decorate the classroom or help decorate the tree?
- Would you rather act in a Christmas play or design the stage?
Related Article: 12 Days of Christmas Games: Fun and Festive Ideas for Everyone
👩💼 Would You Rather Christmas Edition for Adults
(Fun for friends, work parties, or casual conversations)
- Would you rather attend a formal holiday gala or a cozy pajama party?
- Would you rather receive a heartfelt gift or an expensive one?
- Would you rather travel during the holidays or stay local?
- Would you rather skip the shopping or the wrapping?
- Would you rather have your tree up in October or never put one up?
- Would you rather wear an ugly Christmas sweater to work or sing carols in public?
- Would you rather drink only eggnog or mulled wine all season?
- Would you rather host a white elephant exchange or a Secret Santa?
- Would you rather get snowed in or have 80°F weather on Christmas?
- Would you rather rewatch every Hallmark movie or attend one awkward holiday party?
Related Article: 105 Juicy Would You Rather Questions for Adults: Funny, Flirty, and Hard Choices!
🧑🤝🧑 Would You Rather Christmas Edition for Friends
(Great for sleepovers, Zoom calls, or parties)
- Would you rather prank a friend with a fake gift or get pranked?
- Would you rather create a DIY ornament or DIY hot cocoa bombs?
- Would you rather gift socks or candles?
- Would you rather do a TikTok dance to a Christmas song or wear a Grinch costume?
- Would you rather exchange gag gifts or meaningful letters?
- Would you rather go Christmas light hunting or bake cookies?
- Would you rather sing Mariah Carey or Michael Bublé carols in public?
- Would you rather create a holiday meme or a holiday vlog?
- Would you rather do a blindfolded gift wrap race or a candy cane relay?
- Would you rather wear mistletoe earrings or jingle bell socks for a day?
🎉 Funny & Weird “Would You Rather” Christmas Edition
(For belly laughs and wacky fun!)
- Would you rather have candy canes for fingers or marshmallows for toes?
- Would you rather wear a wreath as a hat or tinsel as a scarf?
- Would you rather have Rudolph’s nose or Santa’s beard for a week?
- Would you rather sleep in a giant stocking or under a tree?
- Would you rather get gifts from the Grinch or Krampus?
- Would you rather have to wrap all gifts using only one hand or with your eyes closed?
- Would you rather eat a fruitcake the size of your head or drink pickle-flavored eggnog?
- Would you rather walk around with mistletoe above your head or sleigh bells tied to your shoes?
- Would you rather speak only in rhymes like Dr. Seuss or sing every sentence like a carol?
- Would you rather swap lives with an elf or a snowman?
🧑🏫 Christmas Would You Rather Game Ideas
(Make your questions into activities or challenges!)
- Game Night Spin: Use a spinning wheel to select random questions.
- Vote & Reveal: Use dry erase boards or fingers-up to vote in groups.
- Christmas Charades Hybrid: Act out your choice!
- Write & Pass: Write a “Would You Rather” and swap it like Secret Santa notes.
- Holiday Score Game: Players get points for popular answers.
📦 Printable Use Suggestions (Great for Teachers, Parents, or Hosts)
- Add to classroom centers during December
- Include in Christmas Eve boxes
- Use for Zoom family game night
- Slip one in each advent calendar pocket
- Add to party gift bags as an activity sheet
🎄 Final Thoughts,
There you have it—75+ of the best Would You Rather Christmas Edition questions to liven up any gathering. From playful kid-friendly prompts to clever conversation starters for adults, these festive dilemmas bring out creativity, laughter, and bonding.
No matter your group’s size, setting, or budget, you can easily adapt these Christmas questions for kids, adults, or mixed audiences. Print a few out, add some hot cocoa, and let the fun begin!
So, would you rather wait until next year… or start playing right now?
👉 Grab your favorites, share a few laughs, and create magical memories with these Would You Rather Christmas questions today!
