100+ This or That Questions: Christmas Edition for Holiday Parties
Christmas is the perfect time for cozy traditions, festive food, sparkling decorations, and plenty of laughter. And if you’re looking for an easy game that gets everyone talking, This or That Questions: Christmas Edition is a perfect choice.
The best part? There are no complicated rules, expensive supplies, or long instructions. Players simply choose between two fun Christmas options. Would they rather drink hot cocoa or eggnog? Open presents on Christmas Eve or Christmas morning? Decorate with colorful lights or classic white lights?
This This or That Christmas Edition party game works for families, friends, classrooms, coworkers, and holiday parties. You can play around the dinner table, use the questions as conversation starters, turn them into printable cards, or add them to your Christmas party games.
Below, you’ll find more than 100 festive Christmas this-or-that questions to make your holiday celebration even more fun.
What Is the This or That Christmas Edition Party Game?
This game is wonderfully simple. That’s exactly why people love it.
Everyone gets two choices. They have to pick one.
There are no wrong answers, and the conversations that follow can be surprisingly funny.
For example:
Christmas cookies or Christmas candy?
Players choose their favorite, explain why, and sometimes discover that nobody agrees.
The This or That Christmas Edition party game can be played with almost any group, including:
- Families
- Kids and teens
- Adults
- Friends
- Coworkers
- Classroom groups
- Christmas party guests
- Church groups
Quick tip: Ask players to explain their answers for even more conversation and laughter.
How to Play Christmas This or That
You don’t need much preparation to play.
Simply read one question at a time and let everyone choose between the two options.
Here are a few easy ways to play:
Option 1: Point Left or Right
Assign one answer to the left side and the other to the right.
Players point in the direction of their choice.
Option 2: Move to a Side of the Room
For larger parties, label one side of the room with each answer.
Players walk to the side they choose.
Option 3: Raise Your Hand
Ask players to raise their hands for their favorite option.
This works especially well at dinner or in classrooms.
Option 4: Printable Question Cards
Print the questions, cut them into cards, and place them in a festive bowl.
Players take turns choosing and reading a card.
Pro tip: Mix funny, easy, and debate-worthy questions so the game stays interesting.
Christmas Food This or That Questions
Food is always part of the holiday fun.
These questions may also start a few friendly arguments.
After all, everyone has strong opinions about Christmas treats.
- Christmas cookies or Christmas cake?
- Hot cocoa or eggnog?
- Candy canes or chocolate?
- Gingerbread cookies or sugar cookies?
- Pumpkin pie or apple pie?
- Homemade cookies or store-bought cookies?
- Peppermint or cinnamon?
- Chocolate fudge or caramel fudge?
- Turkey or ham?
- Mashed potatoes or stuffing?
- Sweet potatoes or green bean casserole?
- Christmas breakfast or Christmas dinner?
- Cookie decorating or gingerbread house decorating?
- Hot chocolate with marshmallows or whipped cream?
- Fruitcake or Christmas pudding?
Quick tip: Use these questions during Christmas dinner to get everyone talking between courses.
Related: 25 Christmas Minute to Win It Games for Kids, Adults & Families
Christmas Movies This or That Questions
Christmas movies are a major part of the holiday season.
Some people love funny holiday movies.
Others prefer classic stories with plenty of Christmas magic.
- Funny Christmas movie or romantic Christmas movie?
- Classic Christmas movie or modern Christmas movie?
- Watching at home or going to the theater?
- Christmas comedy or Christmas adventure?
- Animated Christmas movie or live-action movie?
- Watch one movie repeatedly or watch a different movie every year?
- Movie marathon or one Christmas movie?
- Funny holiday characters or magical Christmas characters?
- Santa movie or snowman movie?
- Family-friendly movie or Christmas romance?
- Old-fashioned Christmas story or modern holiday story?
- Watch movies alone or with the whole family?
- Christmas movie with popcorn or cookies?
- Happy ending or surprising ending?
- Watch a movie on Christmas Eve or Christmas Day?
Pro tip: Turn this section into a Christmas movie night voting game.
Christmas Decorations This or That Questions
Decorating is where personal Christmas style really shines.
Some people love a traditional red-and-green Christmas.
Others prefer something modern and minimal.
Which side are you on?
- Real Christmas tree or artificial tree?
- Colorful lights or white lights?
- Classic decorations or modern decorations?
- Red and green or winter white and gold?
- Big Christmas tree or small Christmas tree?
- Minimal decorations or decorations everywhere?
- Traditional ornaments or personalized ornaments?
- Tinsel or garland?
- Tree topper star or angel?
- Matching ornaments or mixed ornaments?
- Natural greenery or glittery decorations?
- Indoor decorations or outdoor decorations?
- Wreath on the door or lights around the house?
- DIY decorations or store-bought decorations?
- Cozy rustic Christmas or elegant Christmas decor?
Quick tip: Ask everyone to choose their answers before decorating together. You might discover why everyone has different decorating opinions!
Related: Christmas Movie Theme Party Ideas to Create a Magical, Cozy, and Unforgettable Holiday Night
Christmas Traditions This or That Questions
Traditions are often what make Christmas feel truly special.
Every family celebrates differently.
These questions are perfect for learning more about each other.
- Open presents on Christmas Eve or Christmas morning?
- Stay home or travel for Christmas?
- Big family gathering or small celebration?
- Matching Christmas pajamas or regular pajamas?
- Christmas Eve party or Christmas Day celebration?
- Wake up early or sleep late on Christmas morning?
- Exchange lots of small gifts or one big gift?
- Secret Santa or traditional gift exchange?
- Handmade gifts or store-bought gifts?
- Christmas cards or digital holiday messages?
- Bake together or decorate together?
- Christmas shopping early or last-minute shopping?
- Plan everything or celebrate spontaneously?
- Quiet Christmas or busy Christmas?
- Follow old traditions or create new traditions?
Pro tip: Ask grandparents or older family members which Christmas traditions they remember most.
Funny Christmas This or That Questions
Now it’s time to get a little silly.
These questions are great for breaking the ice.
Don’t be surprised if the answers lead to lots of laughter.
- Wear an ugly Christmas sweater or a Santa suit?
- Have a snowball fight or build a snowman?
- Be one of Santa’s elves or one of his reindeer?
- Have a Christmas tree that talks or a snowman that talks?
- Eat only Christmas cookies or only candy canes for a day?
- Have tinsel for hair or ornaments for earrings?
- Live at the North Pole or live inside a giant gingerbread house?
- Get stuck in a chimney or stuck inside a giant present?
- Have Rudolph’s nose or elf ears?
- Wear Christmas pajamas everywhere or an ugly sweater every day?
- Have a snowball fight with Santa or a dance competition with elves?
- Only sing Christmas songs or only speak in Christmas movie quotes?
- Have Christmas lights around your bed or ornaments hanging from your backpack?
- Eat a giant candy cane or a giant gingerbread cookie?
- Turn into a snowman or turn into a Christmas elf?
Common mistake: Don’t rush through the funny questions. Let people explain their ridiculous answers!
Christmas Would You Rather: Gifts and Shopping
Gift giving can be exciting.
It can also be a little stressful.
These questions keep the topic fun.
- Receive one surprise gift or choose all your gifts?
- Get one expensive gift or ten small gifts?
- Give gifts or receive gifts?
- Shop online or shop in stores?
- Wrap presents or put them in gift bags?
- Use colorful wrapping paper or simple elegant wrapping paper?
- Buy gifts early or shop at the last minute?
- Give practical gifts or funny gifts?
- Give handmade gifts or purchased gifts?
- Receive something you need or something you want?
- Secret Santa or White Elephant gift exchange?
- Get a mystery gift or know exactly what you’re getting?
- Spend Christmas shopping with friends or family?
- Wrap presents while listening to music or watching a Christmas movie?
- Receive a gift card or a surprise present?
Quick tip: These questions work especially well during a Secret Santa or White Elephant party.
Winter and Christmas This or That Questions
Christmas isn’t only about presents and decorations.
The winter atmosphere can be just as magical.
These questions celebrate the cozy side of the season.
- Snowy day or sunny winter day?
- Stay inside or play outside in the snow?
- Build a snowman or make snow angels?
- Ice skating or sledding?
- Cozy blanket or warm fireplace?
- Cold winter walk or relaxing indoor day?
- Winter cabin or city decorated for Christmas?
- Hot coffee or hot chocolate?
- Read a Christmas book or watch a Christmas movie?
- Cozy socks or fuzzy slippers?
- Snowflakes or icicles?
- Winter vacation or Christmas staycation?
- Sit by the fireplace or under a cozy blanket?
- Fresh winter air or staying warm indoors?
- Early winter mornings or cozy winter nights?
Christmas Questions for Kids
Kids usually have strong opinions about Christmas.
And these simple questions are easy for younger players to answer.
- Santa or Rudolph?
- Cookies or candy canes?
- Presents or Christmas stockings?
- Snowman or Christmas tree?
- Red ornaments or gold ornaments?
- Christmas pajamas or Christmas sweater?
- Build a gingerbread house or decorate cookies?
- Christmas morning or Christmas Eve?
- Santa hat or elf hat?
- Reindeer or polar bear?
- Big Christmas tree or lots of small trees?
- Singing Christmas songs or dancing to Christmas music?
- Snowball fight or Christmas scavenger hunt?
- Open one present early or wait until Christmas morning?
- Visit Santa or write Santa a letter?
Pro tip: For younger children, add pictures to printable question cards to make the game easier to play.
Christmas This or That Questions for Adults
Adults enjoy a good Christmas party game too.
In fact, the right questions can bring coworkers, friends, and family members into the conversation quickly.
These questions are ideal for adult holiday gatherings.
- Host Christmas dinner or attend someone else’s dinner?
- Cook the meal or clean up afterward?
- Christmas cocktail party or cozy movie night?
- Elegant Christmas party or casual pajama party?
- Host a big party or have a quiet evening?
- Decorate in November or wait until December?
- Christmas shopping or Christmas baking?
- Spend money on gifts or experiences?
- Receive fewer meaningful gifts or lots of surprise gifts?
- Christmas vacation or holiday staycation?
- Traditional Christmas dinner or try something completely new?
- Send Christmas cards or make a holiday photo album?
- Spend Christmas at home or travel somewhere new?
- Early Christmas shopping or last-minute shopping?
- A cozy Christmas morning or a big Christmas party?
This or That Christmas Edition Party Game Ideas
The questions are only the beginning.
You can turn this simple game into several fun activities.
Christmas This or That Voting Game
Read each question aloud.
Players vote by raising their hands, pointing, or moving to different sides of the room.
Keep track of the most popular answers.
This works especially well for:
- Office parties
- Large family gatherings
- School groups
- Church events
Christmas This or That Printable Cards
Print each question on a small card.
Place the cards in a festive jar, stocking, or Santa hat.
Players take turns drawing a card.
This creates a simple Christmas party game printable that can be reused every year.
Christmas This or That Challenge
Give players only five seconds to choose.
No changing answers allowed!
This fast-paced version is especially fun for teens and large groups.
Team Christmas Game
Divide players into two teams.
Each team must guess which answer the majority of the group will choose.
Award one point for each correct guess.
The team with the most points wins.
How to Make Your Christmas This or That Game More Fun
A few small details can turn simple questions into a memorable party activity.
Try these ideas:
- Play Christmas music in the background.
- Use festive printable cards.
- Give players Christmas-themed pencils.
- Decorate the question jar.
- Offer a small prize for the funniest answer.
- Ask players to explain surprising choices.
- Take photos of funny reactions.
- Use a timer for quick rounds.
- Mix easy and silly questions.
- Let guests create their own questions.
Pro tip: Start with easy questions and save the funniest ones for later when everyone feels more comfortable.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a good Christmas icebreaker game?
A This or That Christmas Edition party game is one of the easiest Christmas icebreakers because everyone can participate. Players simply choose between two festive options, making it perfect for groups that don’t know each other well.
How many people can play Christmas This or That?
You can play with as few as two people or with a large group. It works for families, classrooms, office parties, and holiday events.
Can you make Christmas This or That into a printable game?
Yes. Print the questions as individual cards or create a worksheet with two options for each question. Printable cards are especially useful for parties and family gatherings.
Are these questions suitable for adults?
Absolutely. Many of the questions work for all ages, while the adult section includes party, hosting, shopping, and holiday tradition topics that are especially fun for grown-ups.
How long does the game take?
A quick round can take 10 minutes. A longer game with 100+ questions and discussion can easily become a full party activity.
Final Thoughts
This This or That Questions: Christmas Edition game is a simple way to bring more laughter and conversation to your holiday celebration. Whether you’re planning a family gathering, classroom activity, office party, or festive night with friends, these questions give everyone an easy way to join the fun.
From Christmas food and decorations to silly choices and holiday traditions, there’s something for every age group. The best part is that you can use the questions in countless ways, including printable cards, voting games, team challenges, and dinner table conversation starters.
Save this list for your next This or That Christmas Edition party game, share it with friends, and add your own festive questions to make the tradition even more personal. After all, sometimes the simplest Christmas games create the best memories.
