This or That Halloween Questions: 230+ Spooky Questions & Best Friend Challenges

Looking for fun This or That Halloween questions to play with your best friend, family, partner, or Halloween party group? You’re in the right place! Halloween is the perfect time for silly choices, spooky debates, hilarious challenges, and questions that reveal just how well your friends know you.

From creepy haunted houses and scary movies to pumpkin carving, Halloween candy, costumes, and supernatural adventures, these This or That spooky edition questions are easy to play anywhere.

You can use them for a Halloween party, sleepover, classroom activity, family game night, Instagram Story, Facebook post, or a fun night with your best friend.

Ready to choose?

Let’s get spooky! 🎃👻

What Is a Halloween This or That Game?

A This or That game is a simple question game where players choose between two options.

For example:

Pumpkin carving 🎃 or Halloween decorating 👻?

You simply choose your favorite.

There are no right or wrong answers. The fun comes from seeing how differently—or surprisingly similarly—you and your friends think.

For an extra challenge, ask everyone to explain why they picked their answer.

100+ This or That Halloween Questions

Here are some fun, spooky, funny, and sometimes difficult Halloween choices to get your game started.

🎃 This or That Halloween Questions

1. Pumpkin carving or pumpkin painting?

2. Trick-or-treating or Halloween parties?

3. Halloween decorations or Halloween costumes?

4. Candy corn or chocolate?

5. Ghosts or witches?

6. Vampires or werewolves?

7. Haunted house or haunted forest?

8. Scary movie or funny Halloween movie?

9. Pumpkin spice latte or hot apple cider?

10. Halloween cookies or Halloween cupcakes?

11. Jack-o’-lanterns or Halloween lights?

12. Black cat or spooky owl?

13. Witch hat or vampire cape?

14. Skeleton decorations or ghost decorations?

15. Orange Halloween décor or black Halloween décor?

16. Spooky music or scary sound effects?

17. Halloween parade or Halloween party?

18. Costume contest or pumpkin-carving contest?

19. Candy apples or caramel apples?

20. Chocolate bars or gummy candy?

21. Halloween morning or Halloween night?

22. Trick-or-treating with friends or family?

23. DIY costume or store-bought costume?

24. Matching costumes or completely different costumes?

25. Cute Halloween or creepy Halloween?

Related: Halloween Would You Rather: 135+ Fun Questions for Kids, Teens & Adults

👻 This or That Spooky Edition Questions

Want something a little creepier? Try these This or That spooky edition questions.

26. Spend a night in a haunted house or an abandoned hotel?

27. See a ghost or hear a ghost?

28. Be chased by a zombie or a werewolf?

29. Explore a haunted mansion or a spooky cemetery?

30. Hear mysterious footsteps or see a shadow move?

31. Have a ghost follow you or a vampire follow you?

32. Spend Halloween alone in a haunted house or with friends in a creepy forest?

33. Watch a horror movie alone or visit a haunted attraction?

34. Sleep in a haunted bedroom or a haunted attic?

35. Hear a strange voice or see a mysterious figure?

36. Find a mysterious old diary or an ancient spellbook?

37. Open a mysterious door or walk down a dark hallway?

38. Meet a friendly ghost or a friendly witch?

39. Have a haunted mirror or a haunted doll?

40. Discover a secret basement or a hidden attic?

41. Hear a creaking floor or a rattling window?

42. Spend the night in a haunted castle or spooky cabin?

43. Encounter a ghostly child or a mysterious old woman?

44. See glowing eyes or hear whispering?

45. Find an unexplained footprint or a mysterious handprint?

46. Walk through fog or walk through a dark forest?

47. Have a spooky dream or hear strange noises while awake?

48. Find a mysterious key or a mysterious treasure chest?

49. Discover a secret passage or a hidden room?

50. Hear a door slam or see a light turn on by itself?

🧙 Halloween Witchy This or That Questions

These are perfect for anyone who loves magical and witchy Halloween vibes.

51. Good witch or mysterious witch?

52. Magic wand or crystal ball?

53. Spellbook or potion bottles?

54. Black cat or magical owl?

55. Witch’s cottage or haunted castle?

56. Flying broomstick or magical portal?

57. Moon magic or star magic?

58. Purple potion or green potion?

59. Witch hat or enchanted cloak?

60. Magical forest or enchanted garden?

61. Fortune-telling or spell casting?

62. Crystal necklace or magical ring?

63. Full moon or crescent moon?

64. Magic mirror or talking cat?

65. Potion-making or spell-making?

Related: Halloween Party Ideas for Adults Theme: Fun, Stylish Ideas

🍬 Halloween Candy This or That Questions

How well do you know your friends’ Halloween candy preferences?

66. Chocolate or gummy candy?

67. Sour candy or sweet candy?

68. Candy corn or chocolate pumpkins?

69. Lollipops or candy bars?

70. Caramel apples or candy apples?

71. M&Ms or Skittles?

72. Chocolate cookies or Halloween cupcakes?

73. Marshmallows or popcorn?

74. Candy necklace or gummy worms?

75. Peanut butter cups or chocolate bars?

76. Sour worms or gummy bears?

77. Candy bucket or candy bowl?

78. One giant candy bar or ten small candies?

79. Homemade Halloween treats or store-bought candy?

80. Eat candy slowly or finish it immediately?

🎃 Halloween Costume This or That Questions

81. Witch or vampire?

82. Ghost or skeleton?

83. Princess or fairy?

84. Superhero or villain?

85. Zombie or monster?

86. Cat or bunny?

87. Pirate or cowboy?

88. Angel or devil?

89. Scarecrow or pumpkin?

90. Matching costumes or individual costumes?

91. Funny costume or scary costume?

92. Cute costume or creepy costume?

93. DIY costume or expensive costume?

94. Face paint or Halloween mask?

95. Full costume or simple accessories?

96. Classic Halloween character or original character?

97. Group costume or couple costume?

98. Costume makeup or costume props?

99. Halloween pajamas or fancy costume?

100. Wear the same costume every year or create a new one every Halloween?

🕸️ Funny This or That Halloween Questions

Not every Halloween question needs to be scary. These funny choices are great for parties and group chats.

101. Have a pumpkin for a head or candy for hair?

102. Talk like a ghost or walk like a zombie?

103. Wear a witch hat every day or vampire cape every day?

104. Eat only candy for dinner or pumpkin soup for dessert?

105. Have a black cat follow you everywhere or a tiny ghost follow you everywhere?

106. Sneeze glitter or sneeze spiderwebs?

107. Have a pumpkin laugh every time you walk past it or a skeleton wave at you?

108. Wear orange every day for a month or black every day for a month?

109. Be chased by ten tiny ghosts or one giant pumpkin?

110. Have a broom that talks or a pumpkin that sings?

111. Live in a haunted house or a giant pumpkin?

112. Have glow-in-the-dark hair or glowing eyes?

113. Turn invisible for Halloween or fly for Halloween?

114. Have a ghost as your roommate or a vampire as your neighbor?

115. Only whisper on Halloween or only shout?

💜 This or That Questions for Best Friends

Want to see how well your best friend knows you? These questions are perfect for a best friend challenge.

116. Halloween movie night or Halloween party?

117. Stay home or go trick-or-treating?

118. Matching Halloween costumes or matching Halloween pajamas?

119. Take Halloween photos or make Halloween videos?

120. Bake Halloween cookies or decorate cupcakes?

121. Watch scary movies or tell scary stories?

122. Pumpkin carving or Halloween crafts?

123. Haunted house or Halloween escape room?

124. Halloween sleepover or Halloween road trip?

125. Dress up or decorate your room?

126. Candy shopping or costume shopping?

127. Take funny photos or spooky photos?

128. Make TikToks or Instagram Reels?

129. Go to a Halloween festival or Halloween party?

130. Have a spooky picnic or cozy movie night?

131. Make a Halloween playlist or Halloween snack board?

132. Visit a pumpkin patch or haunted attraction?

133. Watch horror movies together or comedy movies together?

134. Make homemade costumes or buy matching costumes?

135. Stay up until midnight or wake up early for Halloween breakfast?

👯 Best Friend Challenge Questions

These best friend challenges questions can turn your This or That game into a real friendship challenge.

Take turns answering each question. Before revealing your answer, have your best friend guess what you would choose.

Challenge 1: Guess My Halloween Choice

Ask your best friend:

“Would I choose a haunted house or a Halloween party?”

Write down your answer.

Your friend guesses.

Then reveal the answers.

Give yourselves one point for every correct guess.

Challenge 2: Halloween Best Friend Score

Ask 10 questions from the list.

Your friend must answer what they think you would choose.

Score:

• 9–10 correct: Halloween besties forever! 🎃
• 7–8 correct: You know each other really well!
• 5–6 correct: Not bad!
• 3–4 correct: Time for more best-friend adventures!
• 0–2 correct: You definitely need a Halloween hangout!

🎃 Best Friend Halloween Challenge Questions

Here are some questions specifically designed to test your friendship.

1. What Halloween costume would I choose?

2. What’s my favorite Halloween candy?

3. Would I watch a scary movie alone?

4. Would I enter a haunted house?

5. Would I rather be a witch or vampire?

6. Would I rather decorate pumpkins or bake Halloween cookies?

7. Would I rather have a Halloween sleepover or party?

8. What’s the scariest thing I would actually do?

9. Would I rather see a ghost or a vampire?

10. Would I rather spend Halloween at home or go out?

11. Would I choose a funny costume or scary costume?

12. Would I rather have a black cat or a magical owl?

13. Would I rather explore a haunted house or haunted forest?

14. Would I rather get candy or Halloween gifts?

15. Would I rather watch horror movies or Halloween cartoons?

16. Would I rather dress up as a witch or princess?

17. Would I rather carve a pumpkin or paint one?

18. Would I rather go trick-or-treating or attend a costume party?

19. Would I rather have a ghost roommate or vampire neighbor?

20. Would I rather have a magical Halloween night or a completely normal night?

🧡 Halloween Questions to Ask Your Best Friend

If you want to make the conversation more personal, try these fun questions.

1. What’s your favorite thing about Halloween?

2. What’s your favorite Halloween memory?

3. What’s your dream Halloween costume?

4. What’s the funniest costume you’ve ever worn?

5. What’s the scariest movie you’ve ever watched?

6. What’s your favorite Halloween candy?

7. Would you ever spend the night in a haunted house?

8. Do you believe in ghosts?

9. What’s your favorite Halloween tradition?

10. What’s your favorite Halloween movie?

11. Would you rather have a spooky Halloween party or cozy Halloween night?

12. What’s one Halloween activity you’ve always wanted to try?

13. If we could travel anywhere for Halloween, where would we go?

14. What costume should we wear together?

15. What would our perfect Halloween night look like?

🧛 Halloween Movie This or That Questions

Movie lovers can use these during a Halloween movie night.

1. Horror movie or Halloween comedy?

2. Ghost story or vampire story?

3. Zombie movie or monster movie?

4. Classic horror or modern horror?

5. Haunted house movie or haunted hotel movie?

6. Scary movie or spooky mystery?

7. Watch with the lights on or lights off?

8. Watch alone or with friends?

9. Halloween cartoons or horror movies?

10. Watch one long movie or several short movies?

11. Popcorn or Halloween candy?

12. Cozy blanket or Halloween pajamas?

13. Movie marathon or one favorite movie?

14. Funny scary movie or genuinely terrifying movie?

15. Watch a Halloween movie before sunset or after midnight?

🕯️ Spooky Party This or That Questions

Planning a Halloween party? Add these questions to your party games.

1. Haunted house party or costume party?

2. Halloween dinner or Halloween dessert table?

3. Pumpkin decorations or skeleton decorations?

4. Black candles or orange candles?

5. Halloween balloons or Halloween banners?

6. Spooky photo booth or costume contest?

7. Halloween trivia or Halloween charades?

8. Scary music or fun Halloween songs?

9. Pumpkin-carving station or cookie-decorating station?

10. Halloween punch or hot apple cider?

11. Ghost decorations or witch decorations?

12. Creepy centerpiece or cute centerpiece?

13. Indoor Halloween party or outdoor Halloween party?

14. Halloween scavenger hunt or treasure hunt?

15. Candy bar or dessert table?

👻 How to Play the This or That Halloween Challenge

The game is extremely easy to play.

Step 1: Choose Your Players

You can play with:

• Your best friend
• Family members
• Couples
• Kids
• Classmates
• Party guests
• Online friends

Step 2: Read the Questions

One person reads a question such as:

“Would you rather see a ghost or a vampire?”

Step 3: Choose Quickly

Both players must choose an answer.

For an extra challenge, count down:

3… 2… 1… GO!

Everyone reveals their answer at the same time.

Step 4: Explain Your Choice

The funniest part is often hearing why someone picked their answer.

Step 5: Keep Score

If you’re playing the best-friend version, give one point whenever someone correctly predicts their friend’s answer.

The person with the highest score wins!

🎃 Halloween This or That Questions for Kids

These kid-friendly questions are great for classrooms, family gatherings, and Halloween parties.

1. Pumpkin or ghost?

2. Witch or wizard?

3. Superhero or princess?

4. Chocolate or gummy candy?

5. Pumpkin carving or pumpkin painting?

6. Halloween cookies or cupcakes?

7. Ghost story or funny story?

8. Black cat or owl?

9. Trick-or-treating or costume party?

10. Spooky house or pumpkin patch?

11. Vampire or werewolf?

12. Skeleton or mummy?

13. Orange or purple?

14. Candy bucket or candy bag?

15. Halloween movie or Halloween game?

16. Witch hat or vampire cape?

17. Scary costume or funny costume?

18. Pumpkin pie or apple pie?

19. Halloween crafts or Halloween games?

20. Haunted castle or magical castle?

❤️ Halloween This or That Questions for Couples

Looking for cute questions for a Halloween date night?

1. Halloween movie night or costume date?

2. Matching costumes or surprise costumes?

3. Haunted house or cozy cabin?

4. Pumpkin carving or baking together?

5. Halloween dinner or dessert date?

6. Scary movie or romantic movie?

7. Trick-or-treating or Halloween party?

8. Pumpkin patch or haunted attraction?

9. Cozy blankets or spooky decorations?

10. Halloween photos or Halloween memories?

11. Matching pajamas or matching costumes?

12. Apple cider or pumpkin spice latte?

13. Ghost tour or haunted house?

14. Halloween picnic or dinner at home?

15. Stay in or go out?

🧡 Instagram & Social Media Halloween This or That Ideas

These questions are also perfect for Instagram Stories, Facebook posts, Pinterest content, and group chats.

Try posting two choices and asking followers to pick one.

Example:

🎃 Halloween This or That!

Would you choose:

👻 Haunted House
OR
🎃 Pumpkin Patch?

Comment your choice!

Other quick social media questions include:

• Witch 🧙 or Vampire 🧛?
• Ghost 👻 or Skeleton 💀?
• Candy 🍬 or Costumes 🎃?
• Horror Movie 🎬 or Halloween Party 🕸️?
• Pumpkin Spice ☕ or Hot Cocoa 🍫?
• Haunted House 🏚️ or Haunted Forest 🌲?
• Trick-or-Treat 🍭 or Movie Night 🍿?
• Cute Halloween 🎃 or Spooky Halloween 👻?
• Black Cat 🐈‍⬛ or Owl 🦉?
• Halloween Morning ☀️ or Halloween Night 🌙?

🎃 10 Extra Hard This or That Halloween Questions

These are designed to make everyone think twice.

1. Would you rather spend Halloween in a haunted mansion or a dark forest?

2. Would you rather never eat Halloween candy again or never wear a Halloween costume again?

3. Would you rather be able to see ghosts or talk to them?

4. Would you rather be stuck inside a horror movie or a haunted video game?

5. Would you rather have Halloween every day or Christmas every day?

6. Would you rather face one giant monster or 100 tiny monsters?

7. Would you rather lose your candy or lose your costume?

8. Would you rather spend Halloween without your phone or without candy?

9. Would you rather have a ghost friend or a witch friend?

10. Would you rather know when a ghost is nearby or never know?

🕷️ How to Make the Game More Fun

Want to make your Halloween This or That game even better?

Try these ideas:

Use a Timer

Give players only five seconds to answer.

Fast answers are usually the funniest!

Make Everyone Explain

After every choice, ask:

“Why?”

You may discover some hilarious opinions.

Create a Scoreboard

Give one point for every correct prediction in the best-friend version.

Add a Dare

If someone refuses to answer, they have to complete a harmless Halloween dare.

For example:

• Do your best ghost impression.
• Tell a spooky joke.
• Make a monster sound.
• Walk like a zombie for 10 seconds.
• Sing a Halloween song.
• Do your best witch laugh.
• Tell a funny Halloween story.

Take Screenshots

For online friends, send the questions through a group chat and compare everyone’s answers.

👻 Final Thoughts

These This or That Halloween questions are an easy way to make October more fun. Whether you’re planning a Halloween party, spending the evening with your best friend, enjoying a family game night, or looking for questions to post on social media, there are endless ways to play.

From This or That spooky edition questions and Halloween candy choices to costume debates and best friend challenges questions, these games are designed to get everyone talking, laughing, and sharing their Halloween favorites.

The best part is that you don’t need any special supplies. Just gather your friends, choose a few questions, and start picking sides.

So grab your favorite Halloween candy, put on your costume, turn on some spooky music, and ask:

🎃 Which would you choose? 👻

Happy Halloween and happy playing! 🕷️🍬🧡